Jason Kidd
Steve Nash
or
Isiah Thomas
Who is the better PG all time?
Started by
Pusha Key
, Dec 22 2012 04:01 PM
19 replies to this topic
#1
ONLINE
#2
OFFLINE
#3
OFFLINE
The Logo
-
- Global Moderators
-
- 13,250 posts
Never question the heart of an all time great
-
-
-
Country:
Posted 22 December 2012 - 04:03 PM
Isaiah Thomas easily. Has a championship and was the best player on that team. Thomas is a top 4 PG all time, while Kidd and Nash are both around the top 7-8 range.
- WrongIslander 2.0 likes this
#4
ONLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 04:03 PM
1. Isiah Thomas
2. Jason Kidd
3. Steve Nash
2. Jason Kidd
3. Steve Nash
- Shytown likes this
#5
ONLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 04:09 PM
Isiah Thomas has to be the best of them especially peak and prime wise.
He was a very good scorer (better than his stats would suggest) and he could take over and win the game for his team. Also, as a playmaker he was tremendous. He had a season with 13.9 assists and that says it all. Great leader, fierce competitor and crafty.
Nash and Kidd is debatable but I'd go with Nash. We had that conversation many times before (about those two).
He was a very good scorer (better than his stats would suggest) and he could take over and win the game for his team. Also, as a playmaker he was tremendous. He had a season with 13.9 assists and that says it all. Great leader, fierce competitor and crafty.
Nash and Kidd is debatable but I'd go with Nash. We had that conversation many times before (about those two).
★★★Panathinaikos BC★★★
#6
OFFLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 04:25 PM
I'd take Nash, even though he never won a championship, he does have 2 MVP's. (he should have won a championship btw)
#7
OFFLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 06:03 PM
I would put Nash at 2nd , despite them both failing to get a ring even though they had final appearances . Nash did it better through out his year even managed to win a MVP .1. Isiah Thomas
2. Jason Kidd
3. Steve Nash
"I'm Indubitable, spitting Pharmaceuticals All I do is win, ties are simply unsuitable"
#8
OFFLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 06:06 PM
Isiah
Nash
Kidd
IMO
But a case can be made for any above any.
Nash
Kidd
IMO
But a case can be made for any above any.
- The Future likes this
33 
#9
ONLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 06:17 PM
Just a little correction but J.Kidd did win a ring on the 2011 MavericksI would put Nash at 2nd , despite them both failing to get a ring even though they had final appearances . Nash did it better through out his year even managed to win a MVP .
- Real Deal likes this
List of Real G's in the NBA:
Jamal Crawford, Marshon Brooks, Leandro Barbosa, Ray Allen, LeBron James, Chris Paul, Gordon Hayward, Jonas Valanciunas
Jamal Crawford, Marshon Brooks, Leandro Barbosa, Ray Allen, LeBron James, Chris Paul, Gordon Hayward, Jonas Valanciunas
#10
OFFLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 06:38 PM
Just a little correction but J.Kidd did win a ring on the 2011 Mavericks
+1 and to add to that, Nash has never played in the Finals.
Edited by Real Deal, 22 December 2012 - 06:38 PM.
#11
ONLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 06:51 PM
I think Thomas is the best out of all of them, but I can see why someone would pick Nash. To be honest I've always wanted Thomas and Olajuwon to get more credit than they deserve but it's whatever.
#12
OFFLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 07:59 PM
lol how could I forget that lol my badJust a little correction but J.Kidd did win a ring on the 2011 Mavericks
"I'm Indubitable, spitting Pharmaceuticals All I do is win, ties are simply unsuitable"
#13
OFFLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 09:04 PM
I would put Nash at 2nd , despite them both failing to get a ring even though they had final appearances . Nash did it better through out his year even managed to win a MVP .
Kidd made it to the Finals three times, twice with Nets, once with Mavericks, third was charm with winning a championship with the Mavericks. Steve Nash never made it to the Finals...
I'll choose Kidd, not because of one ring but because of course they both can distribute the ball and both can put the ball in the basket, although Nash wins when it comes to better shooter from long range and short range, but Jason Kidd can rebound the ball and is great defensively whereas Steve Nash is a liability when it comes to defense. If we want to go with some statistics, which is what everyone brings up in the end, stats. Jason Kidd of course has one huge stat over Nash, 1 championship vs 0 for Nash. Steve Nash gets the nod for winning more MVP twice to Jason kidd's zip 0. Kidd has been a All-star 10x in during his career, whereas Steve Nash made it 8x. As I stated before, they are both great distributors, which explains them both leading the league in assist 5x a piece. So when you look at it, it looks kind of even out....
I think most would choose Steve Nash, because of the last few years. Nash looks like the better player older, although this season we have to see how it goes with the Lakers for Nash, Kidd has looked pretty good with the Knicks thus far. I got Kidd, love Nash though.
| Best PG: Rajon Rondo | Fav Defender: Serge Ibaka | Fav PF: Blake Griffin
#14
ONLINE
Posted 22 December 2012 - 09:08 PM
Isiah
Nash
Kidd
In that order
Nash
Kidd
In that order
HNL: Nuggets GM. Two Time HNL Champion
#15
ONLINE
Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:37 AM
I would put Nash at 2nd , despite them both failing to get a ring even though they had final appearances . Nash did it better through out his year even managed to win a MVP .
Steve Nash is better than Jason Kidd offensively, but Kidd is just a better all-around player. 2nd in All-Time Assists, 2nd All-Time Steals, & one of the greatest rebounding guards of all-time.
#16
OFFLINE
WrongIslander 2.0
-
- HN Members
-
- 5,796 posts
Detroit Lions - Inventing new ways to lose since 1994
-
-
Country:
Posted 23 December 2012 - 07:39 AM
Isiah
Kidd
Nash
Kidd
Nash
Atlanta Hawks 2nd overall pick in the 2000 draft: Michael Redd
#17
OFFLINE
#18
ONLINE
Posted 23 December 2012 - 08:04 AM
1: Isaiah Thomas
2: Jason Kidd
3: Steve Nash
2: Jason Kidd
3: Steve Nash
Current Record: #Rebuilding
#19
OFFLINE
Posted 23 December 2012 - 08:08 AM
yea I agree nowSteve Nash is better than Jason Kidd offensively, but Kidd is just a better all-around player. 2nd in All-Time Assists, 2nd All-Time Steals, & one of the greatest rebounding guards of all-time.
"I'm Indubitable, spitting Pharmaceuticals All I do is win, ties are simply unsuitable"
#20
OFFLINE
Posted 23 December 2012 - 03:33 PM
Why is this even a question? Isiah Thomas grills Nash and Kidd alive.
For Nash and Kidd, I would go with Kidd but only by a very thin margin. Kidd's overall game is just unmatched.
For Nash and Kidd, I would go with Kidd but only by a very thin margin. Kidd's overall game is just unmatched.
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users
