16 replies to this topic

[TheJamMasterJ]

Thoughts?

1. CP3
2. Rondo

3-5 for me are pretty open. DWill is not locked for top5 because he's not playing all that great this year.

[Osiris]

Feel bad for Brooklyn that their main piece is Deron Williams..

Anyway, yeah CP3 and Rondo are interchangeable.

[TheJamMasterJ]

Feel bad for Brooklyn that their main piece is Deron Williams..

Anyway, yeah CP3 and Rondo are interchangeable.

That wasn't the question :/

[Sean™]

Based on just this season, yes.

[Osiris]

That wasn't the question :/

Sorry you're right. I was looking at what you posted more towards the question you had in your topic. I think Westbrook's a top 5 PG this season but I'm not sure on Stephen Curry. He's great and he's shown that he's been improving his passing, and his ankles haven't given him a hard time that I know of. So that's a plus. Is he a top 5 PG this year? Sure you could argue that..

I think Kyrie Irving's better than Curry however.

[Young Gee]

Westbrook definitely, hes top 3
Curry no

[BayArea510]

Sorry you're right. I was looking at what you posted more towards the question you had in your topic. I think Westbrook's a top 5 PG this season but I'm not sure on Stephen Curry. He's great and he's shown that he's been improving his passing, and his ankles haven't given him a hard time that I know of. So that's a plus. Is he a top 5 PG this year? Sure you could argue that..

I think Kyrie Irving's better than Curry however.

No.

This year:


1. CP3
2. Rondo
3. Westbrook
4. TP9
5. Holiday/Curry
6. Holiday/Curry
7. Kyrie
8. D-Will

[#1 Euroleague]

No.

This year:


1. CP3
2. Rondo
3. Westbrook
4. TP9
5. Holiday/Curry
6. Holiday/Curry
7. Kyrie
8. D-Will

I think he meant for the entire year, not soley from this year (from the few months of november/dec). that would seem like a rhetorical question/poll and not something one could inform another on, right (presuming he watches games, one person telling him so and so is better wouldn't be informative)? kyrie hasn't missed enough to justify demoting him too far for the entire 82 games, presuming similar play.
1. cp3
2. westbrook
3. rondo
4. curry
5. kyrie

DRose will miss too much to be in top 5.

[The Future]

1.CP3
2.Rondo
3.Kyrie
4.Westbrook
5.Curry


Williams is out because Brooklyn is struggling now.

[Clutch™]

1. CP3
2. Rondo
3. Westbrook
4. Kyrie
5. Curry

So to answer the question, yes.

[The Logo]

This is how my top five so far this season looks like
1. Paul
2. Rondo
3. Westbrook
4. Parker
5. Kyrie
Curry is borderline but credit to him for putting up good stats while leading the Warriors to their best record in a long time.

[MaverixFan]

1.Paul
2. Rondo
3. Westbrook
4. Irving
5. Parker
6. Curry

So Westbrook is but Curry isn't.

[Rio is G.O.A.T]

1: Chris Paul
2: Rondo
3: Irving
4: Westbrook
5: Deron Williams
6: Steph Curry

[Elite Greatness]

1) Paul
2) Rondo
3) Westbrook
4) Parker
5) Curry/Irving

(If Rose was healthy and playing good then I'd put Rose as 2nd)

[airWarrior]

1. CP3
2. Rondo
3. Westbrook
4. Kyrie
5. Curry

So to answer the question, yes.

Agree spot-on

And the Next ones out are Parker, Williams, and Holiday

[JR Swish]

No doubt both Westbrook and Curry are top 5 . They have been playing amazing and deserve to be considered elite guards .

1. CP3
2. Rondo
3. WestBrook
4. Curry
5.Parker

You might question my positioning of Tony Parker but he's been pretty much quiet this season , while curry has been playing wonderful .

[Shytown]

Westbrook, without a doubt. Curry, gotta think about that one...